I guess we all knew this would never work unfortunately, the TV broadcasts can work fine because it is just side by side content that you are giving a live feed to the stereoscopic player and then can output that as you like.
PS3 is a different beast with the whole frame packing method, I think the likely hood of any of the current 720P projectors getting an update to this are slim to none is my opinion.
I guess we all knew this would never work unfortunately, the TV broadcasts can work fine because it is just side by side content that you are giving a live feed to the stereoscopic player and then can output that as you like.
PS3 is a different beast with the whole frame packing method, I think the likely hood of any of the current 720P projectors getting an update to this are slim to none is my opinion.
If anyone has a HDMI 1.4 receiver or similar, and a PS3...maybe they can try this?
I am pretty sure someone will get a hack working for this using an LCD monitor. As long as we can fool the PS3 in thinking that its dealing with a 1.4 TV, and figure out what 3D format its sending to the TV it should be a breeze.
If anyone has a HDMI 1.4 receiver or similar, and a PS3...maybe they can try this?
I am pretty sure someone will get a hack working for this using an LCD monitor. As long as we can fool the PS3 in thinking that its dealing with a 1.4 TV, and figure out what 3D format its sending to the TV it should be a breeze.
Is there any input or video lag? Would this method support checkerboard? I assume it will as long as your computer steroscopic settings indicate you are using a DLP...[/quote]
at my judgement , there are no lag , while im playing it.............
i use 3d vision , samsung 2233rz, acer h5360 ...all runs well ..... so for other kind of 3d glass, i dont have an ability to try it....hehehe.....
Is there any input or video lag? Would this method support checkerboard? I assume it will as long as your computer steroscopic settings indicate you are using a DLP...
at my judgement , there are no lag , while im playing it.............
i use 3d vision , samsung 2233rz, acer h5360 ...all runs well ..... so for other kind of 3d glass, i dont have an ability to try it....hehehe.....
[quote name='BlackSharkfr' post='1071258' date='Jun 10 2010, 05:51 AM']Watch out for hdmi 1.4 handshakes.
Invincible Tiger and Avatar do not use Hdmi1.4, they just display whatever format the user asks.
With the new Sony games if the PS3 detects your capture card is not an Hdmi1.4 device, it may refuse to activate the 3D mode. It all depends on how Sony implements 3D in the games.
They may play fair and let you send the 3D picture to your hdmi1.1 capture card or play rough to force your hand. After all what Sony really wants with this is for you to buy a new 3DTV (preferably a new Sony Bravia 3DTV instead of one of the older competitors)
My guess is they'll play rough : Sony will make it mandatory to use hdmi1.4 frame packing and your capture method won't work.[/quote]
There was an interesting idea proposed on the AVS forums. Using a Geffen HDMI detective someone claims that they were able to sniff out the HDMI EDID of the new Samsung 3D TV and use that to connect it Direct TV box which fooled the box and made it send a side by side 3D signal. Otherwise without the HDMI detective, the Direct TV would not even broadcast the 3D signal to a TV since its looking for the HDMI 1.4 handshake.
I know that you know your 3D stuff and I'm curious if this indeed works, what other possibilities you think can be achieved using this method?
Would a Mitsubishi checkerboard converter work using an EDID from a mitsubishi TV for example? How about using a Nvidia 3D vision capable 120 hz monitor which isn't HDMI 1.4 to play PS3 games by getting an new Bravia 3D ID?
[quote name='BlackSharkfr' post='1071258' date='Jun 10 2010, 05:51 AM']Watch out for hdmi 1.4 handshakes.
Invincible Tiger and Avatar do not use Hdmi1.4, they just display whatever format the user asks.
With the new Sony games if the PS3 detects your capture card is not an Hdmi1.4 device, it may refuse to activate the 3D mode. It all depends on how Sony implements 3D in the games.
They may play fair and let you send the 3D picture to your hdmi1.1 capture card or play rough to force your hand. After all what Sony really wants with this is for you to buy a new 3DTV (preferably a new Sony Bravia 3DTV instead of one of the older competitors)
My guess is they'll play rough : Sony will make it mandatory to use hdmi1.4 frame packing and your capture method won't work.
There was an interesting idea proposed on the AVS forums. Using a Geffen HDMI detective someone claims that they were able to sniff out the HDMI EDID of the new Samsung 3D TV and use that to connect it Direct TV box which fooled the box and made it send a side by side 3D signal. Otherwise without the HDMI detective, the Direct TV would not even broadcast the 3D signal to a TV since its looking for the HDMI 1.4 handshake.
I know that you know your 3D stuff and I'm curious if this indeed works, what other possibilities you think can be achieved using this method?
Would a Mitsubishi checkerboard converter work using an EDID from a mitsubishi TV for example? How about using a Nvidia 3D vision capable 120 hz monitor which isn't HDMI 1.4 to play PS3 games by getting an new Bravia 3D ID?
PS3 is a different beast with the whole frame packing method, I think the likely hood of any of the current 720P projectors getting an update to this are slim to none is my opinion.
PS3 is a different beast with the whole frame packing method, I think the likely hood of any of the current 720P projectors getting an update to this are slim to none is my opinion.
If anyone has a HDMI 1.4 receiver or similar, and a PS3...maybe they can try this?
I am pretty sure someone will get a hack working for this using an LCD monitor. As long as we can fool the PS3 in thinking that its dealing with a 1.4 TV, and figure out what 3D format its sending to the TV it should be a breeze.
If anyone has a HDMI 1.4 receiver or similar, and a PS3...maybe they can try this?
I am pretty sure someone will get a hack working for this using an LCD monitor. As long as we can fool the PS3 in thinking that its dealing with a 1.4 TV, and figure out what 3D format its sending to the TV it should be a breeze.
Is there any input or video lag? Would this method support checkerboard? I assume it will as long as your computer steroscopic settings indicate you are using a DLP...[/quote]
at my judgement , there are no lag , while im playing it.............
i use 3d vision , samsung 2233rz, acer h5360 ...all runs well ..... so for other kind of 3d glass, i dont have an ability to try it....hehehe.....
regards
Is there any input or video lag? Would this method support checkerboard? I assume it will as long as your computer steroscopic settings indicate you are using a DLP...
at my judgement , there are no lag , while im playing it.............
i use 3d vision , samsung 2233rz, acer h5360 ...all runs well ..... so for other kind of 3d glass, i dont have an ability to try it....hehehe.....
regards
i use 3d vision , samsung 2233rz, acer h5360 ...all runs well ..... so for other kind of 3d glass, i dont have an ability to try it....hehehe.....
regards[/quote]
Thanks. Yeah it should work with checkerboard as well since Nvidia drivers would automatically convert.
i use 3d vision , samsung 2233rz, acer h5360 ...all runs well ..... so for other kind of 3d glass, i dont have an ability to try it....hehehe.....
regards
Thanks. Yeah it should work with checkerboard as well since Nvidia drivers would automatically convert.
Invincible Tiger and Avatar do not use Hdmi1.4, they just display whatever format the user asks.
With the new Sony games if the PS3 detects your capture card is not an Hdmi1.4 device, it may refuse to activate the 3D mode. It all depends on how Sony implements 3D in the games.
They may play fair and let you send the 3D picture to your hdmi1.1 capture card or play rough to force your hand. After all what Sony really wants with this is for you to buy a new 3DTV (preferably a new Sony Bravia 3DTV instead of one of the older competitors)
My guess is they'll play rough : Sony will make it mandatory to use hdmi1.4 frame packing and your capture method won't work.[/quote]
There was an interesting idea proposed on the AVS forums. Using a Geffen HDMI detective someone claims that they were able to sniff out the HDMI EDID of the new Samsung 3D TV and use that to connect it Direct TV box which fooled the box and made it send a side by side 3D signal. Otherwise without the HDMI detective, the Direct TV would not even broadcast the 3D signal to a TV since its looking for the HDMI 1.4 handshake.
I know that you know your 3D stuff and I'm curious if this indeed works, what other possibilities you think can be achieved using this method?
Would a Mitsubishi checkerboard converter work using an EDID from a mitsubishi TV for example? How about using a Nvidia 3D vision capable 120 hz monitor which isn't HDMI 1.4 to play PS3 games by getting an new Bravia 3D ID?
Invincible Tiger and Avatar do not use Hdmi1.4, they just display whatever format the user asks.
With the new Sony games if the PS3 detects your capture card is not an Hdmi1.4 device, it may refuse to activate the 3D mode. It all depends on how Sony implements 3D in the games.
They may play fair and let you send the 3D picture to your hdmi1.1 capture card or play rough to force your hand. After all what Sony really wants with this is for you to buy a new 3DTV (preferably a new Sony Bravia 3DTV instead of one of the older competitors)
My guess is they'll play rough : Sony will make it mandatory to use hdmi1.4 frame packing and your capture method won't work.
There was an interesting idea proposed on the AVS forums. Using a Geffen HDMI detective someone claims that they were able to sniff out the HDMI EDID of the new Samsung 3D TV and use that to connect it Direct TV box which fooled the box and made it send a side by side 3D signal. Otherwise without the HDMI detective, the Direct TV would not even broadcast the 3D signal to a TV since its looking for the HDMI 1.4 handshake.
I know that you know your 3D stuff and I'm curious if this indeed works, what other possibilities you think can be achieved using this method?
Would a Mitsubishi checkerboard converter work using an EDID from a mitsubishi TV for example? How about using a Nvidia 3D vision capable 120 hz monitor which isn't HDMI 1.4 to play PS3 games by getting an new Bravia 3D ID?