Any 3D Vision "REALLY READY" Screen I can get these days??
  1 / 2    
I know there are some posts like this but I need some compressed information on that. I am Using a BenQ 24'' 3D Vision ready screen and bought an ACER Predator WQHD screen that was terrible.... I want a WQHD screen that is comparable to the low ghosting effect from the BenQ....I know I am used to my screen and may what you define as low ghosting (crosstalk) is not that what I mean but I’d like to give it a try... Hence, a simple question: WHAT SCREEN I HAVE TO BUY???
I know there are some posts like this but I need some compressed information on that. I am Using a BenQ 24'' 3D Vision ready screen and bought an ACER Predator WQHD screen that was terrible....

I want a WQHD screen that is comparable to the low ghosting effect from the BenQ....I know I am used to my screen and may what you define as low ghosting (crosstalk) is not that what I mean but I’d like to give it a try...

Hence, a simple question: WHAT SCREEN I HAVE TO BUY???

Like my work? Donations can be made via PayPal to: rauti@inetmx.de

#1
Posted 01/14/2019 06:26 PM   
You already asked this some time ago but the answer is still the same. All 3D Vision WQHD 27" TN screens use the same panel made by AU Optronics. So all models here have that pixel inversion issue you have been criticizing. However in my opinion if you don't sit 10 cm close to the dislay you don't notice this. So basically all 27" 3D Vision displays use the same panel and all have the pixel inversion issue: [.]Acer Predator XB2 XB272bmiprz[/.] [.]ASUS ROG Swift PG278QR[/.] [.]ASUS ROG Swift PG278Q[/.] [.]ASUS ROG Swift PG27VQ[/.] [.]Dell S2716DG[/.] Best models are still PG278QR and PG27VQ. You wont get anything better than that concerning WQHD.
You already asked this some time ago but the answer is still the same.
All 3D Vision WQHD 27" TN screens use the same panel made by AU Optronics.
So all models here have that pixel inversion issue you have been criticizing.

However in my opinion if you don't sit 10 cm close to the dislay you don't notice this.

So basically all 27" 3D Vision displays use the same panel and all have the pixel inversion issue:

  • Acer Predator XB2 XB272bmiprz
  • ASUS ROG Swift PG278QR
  • ASUS ROG Swift PG278Q
  • ASUS ROG Swift PG27VQ
  • Dell S2716DG

  • Best models are still PG278QR and PG27VQ. You wont get anything better than that concerning WQHD.

    ASUS ROG Strix GeForce GTX 1080 | Core I7-7700K | 16GB RAM | Win10 Pro x64
    Asus ROG Swift PG278Q 3D Vision Monitor
    Optoma UHD 40 3D Vision Projector
    Paypal donations for 3D Fix Manager: duselpaul86@gmx.de

    #2
    Posted 01/14/2019 07:32 PM   
    Nvm, Pauldusler gave a much better answer
    Nvm, Pauldusler gave a much better answer

    #3
    Posted 01/14/2019 07:35 PM   
    Benq XL3270TX... yes, i know, only in my dreams
    Benq XL3270TX... yes, i know, only in my dreams

    #4
    Posted 01/14/2019 08:01 PM   
    Look for LG of 4K OLED 55"/65" TV of 2015-2016 years. There is fine passive 3D-Stereo at 3840x1080p by 3DVision driver...
    Look for LG of 4K OLED 55"/65" TV of 2015-2016 years. There is fine passive 3D-Stereo at 3840x1080p by 3DVision driver...

    4K3D on passive LG OLED 4K TV 65C6V, GTX 1080 Ti, Win 8.1 64 Pro, i7-7700, 3D-Vision 2 on Benq LW61-LED PJ. HTC Vive. Panasonic Z-10000 3D Camcorder

    #5
    Posted 01/15/2019 09:39 AM   
    Thank You didn't know the VQ nor the Dell. I have a list of 3D VISION READY MONITORS here: http://www.tridimensional.info/dispositivos-3d/computer-screens/
    Thank You didn't know the VQ nor the Dell.

    I have a list of 3D VISION READY MONITORS here:

    http://www.tridimensional.info/dispositivos-3d/computer-screens/

    #6
    Posted 01/15/2019 08:38 PM   
    I'd personally wait and see what hits the market in the following months. 4K with HDR would be strongly considered for future proofing, especially for an avid gamer. I'd also at least buy a 1440P display. [quote="zaibaker69"]Talking about HDR, i discovered this wonderfull thread yesterday, i read all posts of the author. Great advices! Especially how to setup HDR for each sliders the games offer. https://www.resetera.com/threads/hdr-games-analysed.23587/[/quote]
    I'd personally wait and see what hits the market in the following months.

    4K with HDR would be strongly considered for future proofing, especially for an avid gamer.

    I'd also at least buy a 1440P display.


    zaibaker69 said:Talking about HDR, i discovered this wonderfull thread yesterday, i read all posts of the author.
    Great advices!

    Especially how to setup HDR for each sliders the games offer.

    https://www.resetera.com/threads/hdr-games-analysed.23587/

    #7
    Posted 01/16/2019 05:09 AM   
    Is the Swift PG27VQ the newest 3d vision monitor? It would be amazing if the upcoming PG35vq is 3d capable.
    Is the Swift PG27VQ the newest 3d vision monitor?

    It would be amazing if the upcoming PG35vq is 3d capable.

    Intel 5960x, Asus RVE, 16 Gb Ram
    Gtx 980
    Samsung 850 pro 1TB
    Win 10 64

    #8
    Posted 01/18/2019 04:21 PM   
    I may be in thr minority but I actually prefer the Dell for 3D vision. The pixel inversion artifacting seems most tolerable on it, as it is faint vertical lines in areas of ghosting. I had the Asus PG278QR and it's artifacting was in more a checkerboard or honeycomb pattern. It also seemed visible on almost all areas of the screen when up close, not just areas of ghosting. That said, the Asus has slightly less ghosting in general than the Dell but neither has much. It's a pick your poison situation and, fir me, the Dell produced the more desirable 3D experience.
    I may be in thr minority but I actually prefer the Dell for 3D vision. The pixel inversion artifacting seems most tolerable on it, as it is faint vertical lines in areas of ghosting. I had the Asus PG278QR and it's artifacting was in more a checkerboard or honeycomb pattern. It also seemed visible on almost all areas of the screen when up close, not just areas of ghosting. That said, the Asus has slightly less ghosting in general than the Dell but neither has much. It's a pick your poison situation and, fir me, the Dell produced the more desirable 3D experience.

    Gigabyte Gaming 5 Z170X, i7-6700K @ 4.4ghz, Asus GTX 2080 ti Strix OC , 16gb DDR4 Corsair Vengence 2666, LG 60uh8500 and 49ub8500 passive 4K 3D EDID, Dell S2716DG.

    #9
    Posted 01/20/2019 04:08 PM   
    Always been a ton of "really ready screens" people just keep buying non 3d ready screens out of pure ignorance than trying to do half ass edid hacks then complain when they don't get the full experience. It never fails...I met 4 people this month who said their 3D vision experience was horrible and its a gimmick. I then asked on which monitor.....non of the 4 users actually had correct 3d vision ready monitors
    Always been a ton of "really ready screens" people just keep buying non 3d ready screens out of pure ignorance than trying to do half ass edid hacks then complain when they don't get the full experience.
    It never fails...I met 4 people this month who said their 3D vision experience was horrible and its a gimmick.
    I then asked on which monitor.....non of the 4 users actually had correct 3d vision ready monitors

    Gaming Rig 1

    i7 5820K 3.3ghz (Stock Clock)
    GTX 1080 Founders Edition (Stock Clock)
    16GB DDR4 2400 RAM
    512 SAMSUNG 840 PRO

    Gaming Rig 2
    My new build

    Asus Maximus X Hero Z370
    MSI Gaming X 1080Ti (2100 mhz OC Watercooled)
    8700k (4.7ghz OC Watercooled)
    16gb DDR4 3000 Ram
    500GB SAMSUNG 860 EVO SERIES SSD M.2

    #10
    Posted 01/20/2019 09:56 PM   
    [quote="CeeJaySFII"]I may be in thr minority but I actually prefer the Dell for 3D vision. The pixel inversion artifacting seems most tolerable on it, as it is faint vertical lines in areas of ghosting. I had the Asus PG278QR and it's artifacting was in more a checkerboard or honeycomb pattern. It also seemed visible on almost all areas of the screen when up close, not just areas of ghosting. That said, the Asus has slightly less ghosting in general than the Dell but neither has much. It's a pick your poison situation and, fir me, the Dell produced the more desirable 3D experience.[/quote] I'm beginning to think that it is a hit or miss situation, no matter what brand you choose... I have absolutely ZERO pixel inversion on my Asus (It seems might have to stick with it forever:)
    CeeJaySFII said:I may be in thr minority but I actually prefer the Dell for 3D vision. The pixel inversion artifacting seems most tolerable on it, as it is faint vertical lines in areas of ghosting. I had the Asus PG278QR and it's artifacting was in more a checkerboard or honeycomb pattern. It also seemed visible on almost all areas of the screen when up close, not just areas of ghosting. That said, the Asus has slightly less ghosting in general than the Dell but neither has much. It's a pick your poison situation and, fir me, the Dell produced the more desirable 3D experience.


    I'm beginning to think that it is a hit or miss situation, no matter what brand you choose...

    I have absolutely ZERO pixel inversion on my Asus (It seems might have to stick with it forever:)

    Win7 64bit Pro
    CPU: 4790K 4.8 GHZ
    GPU: Asus Geforce RTX 2080 TI Rog Strix OC
    Monitor: Asus PG278QR
    And lots of ram and HD's ;)

    #11
    Posted 01/21/2019 04:37 PM   
    I was/am quite happy with my 1440p s2716dg dell monitor , and I used to have the asus VG278HE and it was awesome too , now I also have a 55C6p 4k tv and it rarely use the monitor anymore for 3d
    I was/am quite happy with my 1440p s2716dg dell monitor , and I used to have the asus VG278HE and it was awesome too , now I also have a 55C6p 4k tv and it rarely use the monitor anymore for 3d

    #12
    Posted 01/21/2019 07:01 PM   
    [quote]You already asked this some time ago but the answer is still the same. All 3D Vision WQHD 27" TN screens use the same panel made by AU Optronics. So all models here have that pixel inversion issue you have been criticizing. However in my opinion if you don't sit 10 cm close to the dislay you don't notice this. So basically all 27" 3D Vision displays use the same panel and all have the pixel inversion issue: •Acer Predator XB2 XB272bmiprz •ASUS ROG Swift PG278QR •ASUS ROG Swift PG278Q •ASUS ROG Swift PG27VQ •Dell S2716DG Best models are still PG278QR and PG27VQ. You wont get anything better than that concerning WQHD. [/quote] What is Pixel Inversion? I have had big Problems with burn in effect with an acer screen. The Picture was present sometimes over seconds on the Screen and the ghosting was horrorible. I cant find any official message/info that the PG278QR is 3D Vision Ready. I am afraid that the 3D experiance is worst than with my BenQ and comparibble to the horrorible Acer i got, because no pfficial 3D Vision Support spec i found??
    You already asked this some time ago but the answer is still the same.
    All 3D Vision WQHD 27" TN screens use the same panel made by AU Optronics.
    So all models here have that pixel inversion issue you have been criticizing.

    However in my opinion if you don't sit 10 cm close to the dislay you don't notice this.

    So basically all 27" 3D Vision displays use the same panel and all have the pixel inversion issue:

    •Acer Predator XB2 XB272bmiprz
    •ASUS ROG Swift PG278QR
    •ASUS ROG Swift PG278Q
    •ASUS ROG Swift PG27VQ
    •Dell S2716DG

    Best models are still PG278QR and PG27VQ. You wont get anything better than that concerning WQHD.


    What is Pixel Inversion? I have had big Problems with burn in effect with an acer screen. The Picture was present sometimes over seconds on the Screen and the ghosting was horrorible.

    I cant find any official message/info that the PG278QR is 3D Vision Ready. I am afraid that the 3D experiance is worst than with my BenQ and comparibble to the horrorible Acer i got, because no pfficial 3D Vision Support spec i found??

    Like my work? Donations can be made via PayPal to: rauti@inetmx.de

    #13
    Posted 01/25/2019 02:31 PM   
    With all respect Losti... You have all the answers right in front of you :) I wrote in post 11: I have absolutely ZERO pixel inversion on my Asus. And it is still a 3D Ready monitor, with sticker on the stand and every thing ;) I know there are other opinions on the matter, which can found on this forum, but most agrees on this one!
    With all respect Losti...

    You have all the answers right in front of you :)

    I wrote in post 11: I have absolutely ZERO pixel inversion on my Asus.
    And it is still a 3D Ready monitor, with sticker on the stand and every thing ;)

    I know there are other opinions on the matter, which can found on this forum, but most agrees on this one!

    Win7 64bit Pro
    CPU: 4790K 4.8 GHZ
    GPU: Asus Geforce RTX 2080 TI Rog Strix OC
    Monitor: Asus PG278QR
    And lots of ram and HD's ;)

    #14
    Posted 01/25/2019 03:10 PM   
    OK Thank you. I have purcheased the ASUS ROG Swift PG278QR now and will Report back if i was able to test it ^^
    OK Thank you. I have purcheased the ASUS ROG Swift PG278QR now and will Report back if i was able to test it ^^

    Like my work? Donations can be made via PayPal to: rauti@inetmx.de

    #15
    Posted 01/29/2019 09:38 AM   
      1 / 2    
    Scroll To Top